Comparison of soil water sensing methods for irrigation management and research
Date
2007-02
Authors
Evett, S. R., author
Howell, T. A., author
Tolk, J. A., author
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Abstract
As irrigation water resources decrease and deficit irrigation becomes more common across the Great Plains, greater accuracy in irrigation scheduling will be required. With deficit irrigation a smaller amount of soil water is held in reserve and there is less margin for error. Researchers investigating deficit irrigation practices and developing management practices must also have accurate measures of soil water content - in fact, the two go hand in hand. New management practices for deficit irrigation will require more accurate assessments of soil water content if success is to be ensured. This study compared several commercial soil water sensing systems, four of them based on the electromagnetic (EM) properties of soil as influenced by soil water content, versus the venerable neutron moisture meter (NMM), which is based on the slowing of neutrons by soil water. While performance varied widely, the EM sensors were all less precise and less accurate in the field than was the NMM. Variation in water contents from one measurement location to the next was much greater for the EM sensors and was so large that these sensors are not useful for determining the amount of water to apply. The NMM is still the only sensor that is suitable for irrigation research. However, the NMM is not practical for on-farm irrigation management due to cost and regulatory issues. Unfortunately, our studies indicate that the EM sensors are not useful for irrigation management due to inaccuracy and variability. A new generation of EM sensors should be developed to overcome the problems of those currently available. In the meantime, tensiometers, electrical resistance sensors and soil probes may fill the gap for irrigation management based on soil water sensing. However, many farmers are successfully using irrigation scheduling based on crop water use estimates from weather station networks and reference ET calculations. When used in conjunction with direct field soil water observations to avoid over irrigation, the ET network approach has proved useful in maximizing yields.
Description
Presented at the 2007 Central Plains irrigation conference on February 27-28 in Kearney, Nebraska.